A brief reminder about the complexity of measuring ‘Demand’ …

…. because it’s not as simple as some might initially think

[This article was initially written as part of this article here on the same day, but has been extracted separately so it can be separately referenced in future]

Those readers who want for the gory details can read them here, but the short story is that there’s essentially three measures of demand that are commonly talked about, and they are not really interchangeable.  Starting from the top and working down…

 

# Measure of demand Brief Explanation

#0

‘Absolutely Everything Consumed’

This is something we don’t hear much spoken about because it would include other things, on the top of ‘Underlying demand’ in that we’d also add in energy consumed via Scheduled Loads (i.e. in charging batteries from the grid and the few pumped hydro as well).

#1

‘Underlying Demand’

This measure is increasingly used, to represent ‘real’ consumption for purposes other than just time-shifting energy:

  • i.e. not batteries charging from the grid, or pumped hydro.
  • though it’s important to note that, by virtue of how it’s approximated, it does consider what would be a growing volume of energy flowing into residential batteries ‘behind the meter’ from rooftop PV systems!

Given the invisibility of some aspects of this ‘behind the meter’ consumption, and also  the ongoing opacity of rooftop PV (which is growing in volume) it seems most people estimate this by adding onto ‘Operational Demand’ the estimate of production from <100kW rooftop PV.

#3

‘Operational Demand’

As we can see from the chart noted in this article on 1st Feb 2025, this measure the AEMO has only been publishing since late 2014 (and then only on a half-hourly basis).  So only ~11 years of history in a market that’s >26 years old.

Some might think about this as ‘Grid Demand’.

AEMO increasingly refers to this because it most closely relates to the consumption that they can ‘see’ in real time, and hence relates to their ‘keeping the lights on’ functions.

#3

‘Market Demand’

This measure the AEMO has been publishing on a 5-minute cadence (i.e. for every dispatch interval) since the start of the NEM.

It’s a number that is fed into NEMDE and hence which plays a key role (along with bidding behaviour) in determining price outcomes.

The MMS field name is ‘TOTALDEMAND’, but ironically it’s not ‘total’ in the layperson sense!

Whilst AEMO increasingly looks at ‘Operational Demand’ many in the wholesale market still look closely at ‘Market Demand’ because that most closely relates to:

  • Which Scheduled and Semi-Scheduled units will be dispatched; and
  • What the prices will be, so what they will be paid.

 


About the Author

Paul McArdle
Paul was one of the founders of Global-Roam in February 2000. He is currently the CEO of the company and the principal author of WattClarity. Writing for WattClarity has become a natural extension of his work in understanding the electricity market, enabling him to lead the team in developing better software for clients. Before co-founding the company, Paul worked as a Mechanical Engineer for the Queensland Electricity Commission in the early 1990s. He also gained international experience in Japan, the United States, Canada, the UK, and Argentina as part of his ES Cornwall Memorial Scholarship.

21 Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. A trend of daily peak NEM-wide ‘Market Demand’– from 1st January 2028 to 31st January 2025 - WattClarity
  2. A trend of daily peak Victoria ‘Market Demand’– from 1st January 2008 to 1st February 2025 - WattClarity
  3. Monday 3rd February could be a big day, in terms of ‘Market Demand’ across the NEM (and in Victoria) - WattClarity
  4. AEMO’s demand forecasts show chance of a bigger demand day declining – for Monday 3rd February 2025 - WattClarity
  5. Demand, and Price, climbing in ‘NEM south’ … particularly Victoria - WattClarity
  6. Remarkable electricity demand outcomes on Monday evening 3rd February 2025 (NEM-wide, in Victoria and South Australia)! - WattClarity
  7. Afternoon volatility in NSW on Tuesday 4th February 2025 - WattClarity
  8. Stubborn forecast LOR2 for NSW on Friday afternoon/evening 7th February 2024 - WattClarity
  9. Large jump in ‘Market Demand’ in NSW on Friday afternoon 7th February 2025 - WattClarity
  10. Some remarks on Victorian demand - WattClarity
  11. Wednesday 12th February 2025 could be a big day for ‘Market Demand’ in South Australia - WattClarity
  12. ‘Market Demand’ soars in South Australia on Wednesday evening 12th February 2025 - WattClarity
  13. Spare capacity in South Australia drops below 100MW on Wednesday evening 12th February 2025 - WattClarity
  14. ‘Lowest ever*’ point for ‘Market Demand’ in NSW crashes lower, on Sunday 16th February 2025 - WattClarity
  15. Curtailment of Large Solar reaches ~72% (NEM-wide) on Sunday 16th February 2025 - WattClarity
  16. Large instantaneous jump in ‘Market Demand’ in NSW on Tuesday afternoon 18th February 2025 - WattClarity
  17. A curious case of some ‘rogue’ sky-high P5 price forecasts for NSW on Thursday 20th February 2025 - WattClarity
  18. Large (+405MW) jump in ‘Market Demand’ in NSW on Thursday 20th February 2025 - WattClarity
  19. Pronounced ramp in ‘Market Demand’, then subsidence, in South Australia on Saturday 22nd February 2025 - WattClarity
  20. ‘Market Demand’ drops 401MW in 5 minutes on Sunday 2nd March 2025 - WattClarity
  21. High level uncertainty about daytime QLD (and to a lesser extent NSW) ‘Market Demand’ with TC Alfred - WattClarity

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


*